On commercial jobs, sound attenuation batts in steel stud partitions are often the cheapest STC points on the whole wall. A batt that costs little more than the labour to set it can lift a basic partition from the high 30s into the mid 40s. But it only does that if it’s the right product, fills the cavity properly, and isn’t asked to do a job it can’t.
Commercial acoustic insulation is also widely misunderstood. A high R-value says nothing about sound. Two batts with the same lab rating can sound very different on site. And no insulation can fix a wall that leaks around its edges.
This guide is for fit-out contractors, specifiers and general contractors. It covers what cavity insulation does, how mineral wool vs fiberglass compare as commercial acoustic insulation, where dense-pack cellulose fits, how to install batts in a steel stud cavity, and how to specify safely. It comes from the field crews behind our work as commercial insulation contractors in the Greater Toronto Area.
What Commercial Acoustic Insulation Does in a Wall
An empty stud cavity behaves like a small drum. Sound coming through one layer of drywall bounces back and forth inside the cavity and builds up, especially at certain frequencies, before passing into the far layer. Fibrous insulation soaks up that bouncing energy, turning it into a tiny amount of heat as air moves through the fibres.
That makes insulation very good at some jobs and useless at others:
- It absorbs sound in the cavity. In a light-gauge steel stud wall, filling the cavity typically adds around 5 to 8 STC points over an empty one, one of the best returns on the wall.
- It adds no meaningful mass. A batt weighs almost nothing next to drywall, so it can’t replace an extra layer of board.
- It can’t stop vibration through the framing. Where both faces are screwed to the same rigid studs, sound crosses through the studs, and insulation has no effect on that path. This is why insulation adds much less to wood stud walls than to steel.
- It can’t fix flanking. Gaps at the floor and deck, back-to-back outlets and walls that stop at the ceiling leak sound however well the cavity is filled.
- It can make the cavity airtight (dense-pack only). Packed cellulose fills every void and restricts air movement inside the wall; batts can’t.
Think of insulation as one of four levers in a quiet wall, alongside mass, damping and decoupling. It is the cheapest lever, but it only works with the others.
Sound Attenuation Batts: Mineral Wool vs Fiberglass
Sound attenuation batts (SAB) are unfaced batts sized to friction-fit between studs. In commercial work the choice is usually between mineral (stone) wool, such as ROCKWOOL AFB, and acoustic fiberglass batts such as Owens Corning QuietZone. Dense-pack cellulose, the third option, is covered in the next section.
| Mineral wool SAB (ROCKWOOL AFB) | Fiberglass SAB (Owens Corning QuietZone) | |
|---|---|---|
| Density | About 2.5 to 3.0 lb/ft³ | Roughly 0.5 to 1.0 lb/ft³ |
| NRC (sound absorption) | High, around 1.0 at typical thicknesses | High in lab tests at similar thickness |
| STC contribution in steel stud walls | Strong; an edge at lower frequencies from higher density and airflow resistance | Close in lab tests; in our experience, noticeably weaker on site |
| Fire rating | Non-combustible under CAN/ULC-S114; very high melting point; named in many fire-rated assemblies | Glass fibre with a lower melting point; accepted where the fire listing names it |
| Sag resistance | High: stiff, friction-fits and stays put on tall walls | Lower: softer, can slump or sag if poorly fitted |
The surprise for many clients: in lab tests, a fiberglass batt and a mineral wool batt of the same thickness perform very similarly. In real life, there is a clear audible difference. Filling the cavity completely, with a denser material, makes the biggest difference on site.
Mineral wool’s non-combustibility also matters where insulation sits in a plenum or return-air space, or anywhere the fire listing calls for it. So the choice usually comes down to two other things. Fire: if the wall is part of a rated assembly, use the insulation the listing names, and many commercial listings call for mineral wool. Cost: because fiberglass looks almost identical on paper, many contractors choose it to save money. We have learned that in many cases the whole assembly underperforms with fiberglass.
AFB is ROCKWOOL’s commercial product, sized for steel stud spacing and widely used in rated assemblies. Safe’n’Sound is the retail version of a similar stone wool. On a commercial wall, check that the product you install is the one the fire listing or acoustic test actually names.
Dense-Pack Cellulose: Greenfiber SANCTUARY for Walls
Batts are not the only way to fill a cavity. Dense-pack cellulose is about 80% recycled paper fibre, treated with about 20% minerals for fire and pest resistance. It is blown into the cavity under pressure until it is packed solid at about 4 lb per cubic foot, far denser than any batt. Greenfiber’s SANCTUARY is an all-in-one cellulose that can be blown in, dense-packed or spray-applied, and it is the product we install most.
We use it almost everywhere. The only times we don’t are when:
- The cavity has to stay open
- The environment is very humid
- The material must be non-combustible, such as around chimneys and fireplaces
- Our equipment can’t reach the area, as in some condos and office towers
Why Dense-Pack Works for Sound
- It fills 100% of the cavity. Cellulose packs from side to side and top to bottom, around wiring, electrical boxes, blocking and bridging, with none of the gaps and voids a hand-cut batt can leave.
- It stops air moving through the wall. Where air flows, sound follows. Packed cellulose is denser than most batts and restricts airflow inside the cavity, closing small leakage paths and making the cavity nearly airtight.
- It absorbs sound like other fibrous fills, turning cavity resonance into heat.
What the Tests Show
Greenfiber publishes laboratory and field acoustic tests for its cellulose. Highlights:
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| 2×4 wood stud wall, cellulose fill | STC 40 (cellulose adds about 5 points) |
| 2×6 wood stud wall, cellulose fill | STC 44 (cellulose adds about 9 points) |
| Steel stud walls, one layer of 5/8″ board each side, studs at 24″ o.c., cellulose fill | From STC 50 with 2-1/2″ studs to the mid-50s with 3-5/8″ studs and resilient channel |
| Staggered-stud U370 2-hour firewall | STC 56 with one layer of board, up to STC 63 with two |
| Field test, identical homes, exterior walls | NIC 44 with cellulose vs NIC 40 with fiberglass batts |
These are the manufacturer’s published results. For a wall that will be specified or field-tested, design from the specific test report for that assembly.
Retrofitting Existing Walls and Ceilings Without Demolition
Dense-pack’s biggest advantage in commercial work is that it can go into a wall or ceiling that is already closed. Installers drill small holes into each stud or joist bay, blow cellulose in under pressure until the cavity is packed, then patch and refinish the holes. There is no demolition, no dumpster and far less disruption, so clinics, offices and tenants can stay in place.
It is the right fix when the problem is an empty or poorly filled cavity. It can’t add decoupling to rigid framing or close leaks at outlets and the head of the wall, so on a failed partition we pair it with sealing those paths.
FROM THE FIELD
Our dense-fill method needs no drywall removal and no demolition. We drill holes of about 4″ and pump the cavity full under pressure with specialized equipment. It typically takes walls and ceilings well above STC 52, at about a third of the cost of tearing out and rebuilding.
Fire, Moisture and Settling
- Fire: SANCTUARY is borate-treated for fire and pest resistance, and Greenfiber’s U370 assembly reaches a 2-hour fire rating in a 10″ wall. Most commercial steel stud fire listings name mineral wool or glass fibre, so on a rated wall, confirm the listing covers cellulose before using it.
- Moisture: cellulose must stay dry. Keep it out of wet areas and walls exposed to water.
- Settling: dense-packed at the right density, it won’t settle; cellulose holds its place in a closed cavity. Loose-fill cellulose in an open attic is a different application.
Installing Sound Attenuation Batts in Steel Stud Partitions
For a standard 3-5/8″ steel stud wall, a 3″ to 3-1/2″ batt fills the cavity and delivers most of the acoustic benefit available. Getting the fit right matters more than getting the thickness right. Batt work is usually priced and scheduled as part of commercial acoustic insulation and batt installation, and it has to be coordinated with the light-gauge steel stud partition framing, because the stud spacing and depth set the batt width and thickness.
CRITICAL SPECIFICATIONS
- Friction fit: use batts sized about 1/2″ wider than the cavity for the stud spacing (16″ or 24″ o.c.), so they stay suspended in the wall without mechanical fasteners.
- Don’t over-compress: a batt crammed into a shallow steel stud cavity presses against the drywall and can bridge vibration from face to face. Match the batt to the stud depth and leave it relaxed, so the cavity keeps its decoupling.
- Mineral wool where it counts: at about 2.5 to 3.0 lb/ft³, mineral wool damps lower frequencies better than lighter fiberglass, and its CAN/ULC-S114 non-combustibility suits plenum and return-air locations.
- Buy batts made for steel stud spacing. Wood-stud widths are narrower and leave gaps along every stud.
- Fill the open side of the C. Steel studs are open on one side. Tuck the batt edge into the stud’s channel so there’s no air gap running the height of the wall.
- No gaps at the top and bottom. Cut batts to length so they reach the tracks. A strip of empty cavity at the top of a tall wall is a common leak.
- Work around boxes, don’t skip them. Split the batt behind and around outlet and switch boxes rather than leaving the bay empty.
- Keep it in place on tall walls. Softer batts can slump over time. Mineral wool, or a few support clips or wires, keeps the fill where it belongs.
Why Thermal R-Value Doesn’t Equal Acoustic STC
R-value measures how well a material slows the flow of heat. STC measures how well a whole wall assembly blocks airborne sound. They are different physics, and one tells you nothing reliable about the other.
What makes a good acoustic fill is open, fibrous structure: air moving through tangled fibres loses energy. Thermal performance depends mostly on trapping still air. Some materials are excellent at both, some at only one:
- Fibrous batts (mineral wool, fiberglass) are good at both, which is why they’re the standard for acoustic partitions.
- Closed-cell spray foam has one of the highest R-values per inch, but it’s rigid and closed, so it absorbs little sound. Because it bonds to both faces of a wall, it can even tie them together and carry vibration across.
- Rigid foam boards have high R-values but are poor sound absorbers.
So don’t choose acoustic insulation by its R-value, and don’t assume a product sold as “thermal” is acoustically useless either. An unfaced fiberglass thermal batt that fills the cavity often tests close to a branded sound batt. Judge acoustic insulation by its fit, its fill and the tested assembly it belongs to.
Specifying SAB: Product Equivalents and Substitution Risks
Insulation looks like the easiest item on the job to substitute. It’s also one of the easiest to get wrong, because the batt is often part of two separate tests: the wall’s fire rating and its acoustic rating.
Before approving an “or equal,” check:
- The fire listing. If the wall is a rated assembly, the listing may name the insulation type, thickness and density, or require mineral wool. A cheaper fiberglass batt can void the rating.
- The acoustic test. If the design relies on a specific test report, confirm the substitute matches the tested product’s thickness and fill.
- Thickness and fill, not just the product name. A thinner batt or a partial fill changes the result.
- Fire and smoke classifications. For Canadian projects, confirm the product’s mineral fibre and flame-spread certifications (such as CAN/ULC-S702 and CAN/ULC-S102) meet the spec.
- Batt width for the framing. Steel stud widths, not wood.
The cleanest specifications describe the insulation by performance and fit (type, thickness, density range, fire classification and steel stud width) and list two or three named products that meet it. That keeps competitive pricing without opening the door to a substitute that quietly breaks a listing.
Where SAB Fits in a High-STC Wall
Insulation is usually the first upgrade on a commercial partition, not the last. Once the cavity is filled, the next points come from the board and the framing. Add mass and damping with soundproof drywall assemblies, then break the path through the studs with resilient channel and decoupling. An STC 55+ wall uses all three, and the insulation is what makes the decoupled cavity work.
Planning acoustic walls or high-STC separation? Discover how integrating our steel framing, insulation and drywall assemblies under a single contract ensures guaranteed sound isolation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is mineral wool better than fiberglass for soundproofing?
In lab tests they’re usually within a point or two of each other at the same thickness in a steel stud wall. On site, mineral wool’s higher density gives a clear audible edge, especially at lower frequencies. It also wins on fire performance, moisture resistance and staying in place, and many fire-rated listings require it.
How much STC do sound attenuation batts add to a steel stud wall?
Filling the cavity of a light-gauge steel stud partition typically adds around 5 to 8 STC points over an empty cavity. In a wood stud wall the gain is smaller, because sound crosses through the rigid studs.
Does spray foam soundproof a wall?
Not well. Closed-cell spray foam is excellent thermal insulation, but it’s rigid and absorbs little sound, and because it bonds to both faces it can carry vibration across the wall. For acoustic partitions, fibrous fills such as mineral wool and dense-pack cellulose perform far better.
Request Sound Insulation Pricing for Multi-Unit or Office Projects
Tell us about your partitions: the wall types, the STC targets and any fire-rated assemblies. We’ll confirm the insulation each listing calls for, recommend batts sized for your framing, and price the insulation on its own or with the framing and board as one acoustic scope, with an itemized bid breakdown within 24 to 48 business hours.Get a QuoteCall (416) 466-1476
CSI 07 21 16 BLANKET INSULATION